The Star Beacon; Ashtabula, Ohio

World, nation, state

June 15, 2013

Charla Nash denied permission to sue Connecticut over 2009 chimp attack

HARTFORD, Conn. — A multimillion-dollar claim against the state of Connecticut by Charla Nash — blinded in a 2009 mauling by a 200-pound chimpanzee that tore off her face — was dismissed Friday by state Claims Commissioner J. Paul Vance Jr.

Vance’s decision denies Nash permission to sue the state in Superior Court for $150 million for allegedly failing in its regulatory duty to protect the public — including her — from dangerous animals.

The state enjoys “sovereign immunity” against most lawsuits for damages unless the claims commissioner grants permission to bring an action in state court.

Nash, 59, whose injuries required a face transplant, still has a chance to appeal to the state General Assembly to reverse Vance’s decision and let her make her case in court.

In a five-page decision released Friday afternoon, Vance announced that he had granted a motion by state Attorney General George Jepsen’s office to dismiss Nash’s claim.

Nash received a successful face transplant in 2011, two years after the attack by the 14-year-old chimp, Travis. The chimp was owned by her friend and employer, Sandra Herold, who died in 2010. A transplant to give Nash new hands was unsuccessful. She lost all of one hand in the attack, and all but the thumb of the other.

Vance held a lengthy hearing on the claim last August.

“While it is lamentable that Ms. Nash was injured by the chimpanzee, in order to overcome the presumption of sovereign immunity. she must show that the legislature either expressly or by implication, waived the state’s sovereign immunity,” Vance wrote in his decision. “At the time Ms. Nash was attacked, there was no statute that prohibited the private ownership of the chimpanzee nor was there any statutory language that would have created a duty (by the state) to Ms. Nash as a private person.”

Nash and her lawyers argued otherwise.

Nash said last year that she believes that state environmental officials “failed to do their job” by ignoring warnings that the dangerous animal should be removed from Herold’s home in Stamford, Conn. The attack happened on Feb. 16, 2009, when Nash answered Herold’s call to help return Travis to his cage, after the animal had escaped and was roaming out of control on the property.

Jepsen’s office had argued that Vance should deny Nash permission to sue the state in court because of a body of law called the “public duty doctrine.” Under that doctrine, Jepsen’s office said, the state has a duty to protect the general public in regulatory matters, but not any specific individual who might be injured by a person who is not complying with state regulations.

Assistant Attorney General Maite Barainca asked rhetorically at least year’s hearing “what would happen” to state taxpayers if they were exposed to “limitless claims” in court every time there was “a perceived failure to regulate?”

Nash’s attorney, Charles Willinger of Bridgeport, Conn., countered at the hearing that Travis was “an accident waiting to happen.” He was quoting a phrase originally used in late 2008 by a state Department of Environmental Protection official, Elaine Hinsch, in a memo warning other officials at the agency that Travis had grown too big, powerful and dangerous to remain with Herold.

The DEP, now known as the Department of Energy and Environmental Protection, took no action on Hinsch’s memo — written 3 1/2 months before the attack — even though Willinger said that it had the legal authority to seize Travis as an unlicensed, “illegally possessed” animal that “had the strength of five or six adults.” Willinger said “that’s where the liability lies,” adding that state officials were “wrong morally” and “wrong legally,” because they “turned a deaf ear to a foreseeable risk.”

However, Vance wrote: “It would exceed the scope” of his authority “to assume any intent of the legislature where there is no clear language, or evidence of intent in the statute, to support the claimant’s position that (state statutes) required seizure of the animal and also created a duty of care to the claimant.”

Jepsen’s office argued that Nash’s proper route was to seek damages from the estate of Herold, the chimp’s owner - which she and her lawyers did, while also filing the claim to sue the state.

In that Superior Court case against Herold’s estate, a $4 million settlement was reached in December, turning over to Nash nearly the full amount of Herold’s net worth.

Herold had no insurance for either her business or her home, but her estate was worth about $4.5 million, Willinger said at the time. Under terms of the settlement announced in December, Herold’s estate was to provide Nash with $3.4 million in real estate; $331,000 in cash; $140,000 in machinery and equipment; and $44,000 in vehicles.

Text Only
World, nation, state
  • Lordstown eyes fall rollout of updated Cruze

    Production of the updated Chevrolet Cruze is tentatively set to begin early this fall at the General Motors facility in Lordstown, a plant official confirmed.

    April 17, 2014

  • A year after background check defeat, modest goals

    Democratic worries about this November’s elections, a lack of Senate votes and House opposition are forcing congressional gun-control supporters to significantly winnow their 2014 agenda, a year after lawmakers scuttled President Barack Obama’s effort to pass new curbs on firearms.

    April 17, 2014

  • College Board provides a glimpse of new SAT

    Anxious students — not to mention their parents — can get a heads-up for how the redesigned SAT might look in two years.

    April 17, 2014

  • Screen Shot 2014-04-16 at 12.51.22 PM.png VIDEO: Toddler climbs into vending machine

    A child is safe after climbing into and getting stuck inside a claw crane machine at a Lincoln, Neb., bowling alley Monday.

    April 16, 2014 1 Photo

  • Poll finds Clinton trouncing entire GOP field

    Hillary Clinton isn’t only the strong front-runner for the 2016 Democratic presidential nomination, but she’s well ahead of every potential Republican rival, according to a new McClatchy-Marist Poll.

    April 16, 2014

  • Ukraine bares teeth against eastern uprising

    In the first Ukrainian military action against a pro-Russian uprising in the east, government forces repelled an attack Tuesday by about 30 gunmen at an airport, beginning what the president called an “anti-terrorist operation” to try to restore authority over the restive region.

    April 16, 2014

  • U.N. Security Council sees grim images of Syrian dead

    The U.N. Security Council fell silent Tuesday after ambassadors viewed a series of ghastly photographs of dead Syrian civil war victims, France’s ambassador said. The pictures showed people who were emaciated, with their bones protruding, and some bearing the marks of strangulation and repeated beatings, and eyes having been gouged out.

    April 16, 2014

  • U.S.: Russia causing Ukraine unrest

    The White House on Monday said there was “overwhelming evidence” that Russia is fomenting unrest in eastern Ukraine, but suggested that President Barack Obama has not yet concluded that Vladimir Putin’s actions warrant broader sanctions on key Russian economic sectors.

    April 15, 2014

  • Woman arrested after dead babies found

    A Utah woman accused of killing seven babies she gave birth to over 10 years was arrested Sunday after police discovered the tiny bodies stuffed in separate cardboard boxes in the garage of her former home.

    April 14, 2014

  • Rome man killed in crash

    The Ohio State Highway Patrol Chardon Post is investigating a fatal crash that took place just after midnight Sunday.

    April 14, 2014

House Ads

Click HERE to read all your Parade favorites including Hollywood Wire, Celebrity interviews and photo galleries, Food recipes and cooking tips, Games and lots more.
AP Video