The Star Beacon; Ashtabula, Ohio

World, nation, state

April 5, 2012

Ohio justices debate legal consult for juveniles

COLUMBUS —  The Ohio Supreme Court is expected to decide soon whether to require juvenile offenders facing the possibility of detention to consult with an attorney before deciding to waive their right to a lawyer.

Current court rules don’t require such a meeting, and the proposal is pitting youth advocates against some judges who say the requirement hinders the rights of parents and juveniles to make the decision themselves.

The push for the change is almost a decade old, dating to a 2003 American Bar Association report that found many poor children in the state routinely waived their right to an attorney. Three years later, an analysis of 2004 state data found that two in every three children facing a juvenile charge did so without an attorney.

“There’s a culture in a lot of counties that doesn’t really utilize public defenders or appointed counsel,” said Kim Tandy, executive director of the Children’s Law Center in Covington, Ky.

The proposal would make the consultation mandatory for all situations where a juvenile might face detention, even for something as minor as petty theft. An alternative, to make the consultation mandatory only for the most serious charges, doesn’t go far enough, Tandy said.

Juvenile judges in more than 60 counties have expressed their concern about the proposal, most voicing similar concerns about cost, court resources and the interference with parental authority.

Lake County Juvenile Court in Painesville has only two juvenile public defenders in a system that handles more than 3,000 juvenile cases a year, Christopher Simon, the court’s administration director, told the Supreme Court in a Feb. 27 letter.

“The time it would take for a Public Defender to have this discussion with the thousands of cases each year would certainly slow the court process,” he wrote.

Geauga County Juvenile Judge Timothy Grendell has gathered petitions from many judges as he challenges the proposal, which he says amounts to an unfunded mandate on counties already stretched thin.

“Juvenile judges are in the best position to explain the right to counsel to a juvenile and parents and to determine if and when legal counsel is appropriate for a juvenile based on the facts and circumstances of the case,” according to the petition Grendell has helped circulate.

Retired minister Ronald Payne supports the proposal, saying he’s convinced his teenage son avoided serious penalties as a high school student in the 1980s near Toledo when a rock he threw over an overpass as part of a game with friends accidentally hit a tractor-trailer.

A family friend offered his law firm’s help, and the boys got off with a severe reprimand from a juvenile magistrate and the cost of the damage to the truck, Payne said Wednesday.

“I don’t mean to say they weren’t responsible — they should have known better — but it was a stupid thing to do, not a malicious thing, and an attorney helped a magistrate see that,” said Payne.

The requirement is supported by the American Civil Liberties Union and the Ohio Public Defender’s Office. It is opposed by judicial groups and the County Commissioners Association of Ohio.

Eight states require consultation with an attorney before waiving legal rights under certain circumstances, including Alaska, Florida and Maryland, and several others prohibit waiving the right to a lawyer in some form, according to the National Juvenile Defender Center.


Andrew Welsh-Huggins can be reached at

Text Only
World, nation, state
  • 40 bodies from jet solemnly returned to Dutch soil

    Victims of the Malaysian jetliner shot down over Ukraine returned at last Wednesday to Dutch soil in 40 wooden coffins, solemnly and gently carried to 40 identical hearses, flags at half-staff flapping in the wind.

    July 23, 2014

  • U.S. pushes for truce as Gaza battle rages

    The United States announced signs of progress in cease-fire talks Wednesday, but prospects for a quick end to the fighting were dim as Palestinian families fled fierce battles in southern Gaza and the death toll rose to more than 700 Palestinians and 34 Israelis.

    July 23, 2014

  • GROUNDED U.S., other countries ban flights to and from Israel

    A Hamas rocket exploded Tuesday near Israel’s main airport, prompting a ban on all flights from the U.S. and many from Europe and Canada as aviation authorities responded to the shock of seeing a civilian jetliner shot down over Ukraine.

    July 23, 2014

  • REPORT: Retaliation by supervisors common at VA

    A pharmacy supervisor at the VA was placed on leave after complaining about errors and delays in delivering medications to patients at a hospital in Palo Alto, California. In Pennsylvania, a doctor was removed from clinical work after complaining that on-call doctors were refusing to go to a VA hospital in Wilkes-Barre.

    July 22, 2014

  • Veteran's Ducks Iraq vet cited for owning 14 therapeutic pet ducks

    An Army veteran who hurt his back during the Iraq War is worried a citation will result in him losing his 14 pet ducks, which he says are therapeutic.

    July 21, 2014 1 Photo

  • Stacked Apartment.jpg New York building shows how mod design stacks up as cool

    In a city piled high with ambitious architecture, a seven-floor structure off the beaten path boasts a distinction of its own: It’s billed as the first multistory, modular-built apartment building to open in the nation’s apartment capital.

    July 21, 2014 1 Photo

  • Scores dead in first major ground battle in Gaza

    The first major ground battle in two weeks of Israel-Hamas fighting exacted a steep price Sunday: It killed 65 Palestinians and 13 Israeli soldiers and forced thousands of terrified Palestinian civilians to flee their neighborhood, reportedly used to launch rockets at Israel and now devastated by the fighting.

    July 21, 2014

  • Traditional lottery games hold their own

    Ohio’s traditional lottery games are mostly doing well despite competition from their electronic counterparts at four racinos.

    July 20, 2014

  • HIV diagnosis rate fell by third in U.S. over decade

    The rate of HIV infections diagnosed in the United States each year fell by one-third over the past decade, a government study finds. Experts celebrated it as hopeful news that the AIDS epidemic may be slowing in the U.S.

    July 20, 2014

  • Suddenly, the sun is eerily quiet: Where did the sunspots go?

    The sun has gone quiet. Almost too quiet.

    July 20, 2014

House Ads

Click HERE to read all your Parade favorites including Hollywood Wire, Celebrity interviews and photo galleries, Food recipes and cooking tips, Games and lots more.
AP Video