The Star Beacon; Ashtabula, Ohio


August 12, 2013

A Don McCormack column: While noble in concept, school districts already have enough on their plates

The fact the Struthers school district will be testing student-athletes for drugs beginning with the upcoming school year may seem to be a radical step around these parts, but in truth, the concept is anything but trendsetting nationally.

In fact, in the early 1990s, many school districts across the country began to kick the tires on drug testing as a way  to try and combat drug and alcohol abuse by the young people who make up their district.

As expected, that idea led to what often happens — legal action.

In two United States Supreme Court cases — in 1995 and 2002 — the court upheld the constitutionality of testing  student-athletes for drugs and alcohol to include all students who participate in a particular competitive extracurricular activity.

In both of its rulings, he court said deterring drug or alcohol abuse was more important than privacy.

Fair enough.

But the elephant in the room is this question — does it work?

Reverse effect?

The University of Michigan tackled the subject head on, conducting a comprehensive study of the concept of high schools testing student-athletes for drugs and alcohol in 2003.

That groundbreaking study concluded that, believe it or not, at school districts that had testing policies in place, the percentage of student-athletes testing positive was slightly higher than those without policies in place.

The conclusions of the study showed that 21 percent of student-athletes were using drugs or alcohol — compared to 19 percent at districts without policies.

Those results were confirmed by a study conducted by the National Center for Educational Evaluation.

Gender issues

A more recent study, conducted by the University of Pennsylvania, concluded that policies testing for drugs or alcohol did not stop male student-athletes from using either.

The same study concluded having testing policies in place on served as a deterrent for female student-athletes in districts that boasted of positive student-educator relationships and clearcut rules.

Text Only
  • Olivia In transition

    Pymatuning Valley graduate Olivia Holt had a distinct reason she chose to play basketball for Mount Union.
    “They do have tradition,” Holt, the daughter of Gus and Michelle Holt, said. “I’m from PV. We had a tradition of winning and working hard there. I wanted to go somewhere that tradition mattered. I knew I was going to get better by coming here.”

    April 16, 2014 1 Photo

  • Don A Don McCormack column: Spring has sprung one big leak

    Paying a Wednesday morning visit to the variety store...

    Think spring?
    If this, um, err, uh... spring... feels a bit unusual for high school baseball and softball teams in Northeast Ohio, it is, to a point.

    April 16, 2014 1 Photo

  • Scholastic Statistics:

    St. John 4, Euclid 1
    at Pine Lake

    April 16, 2014

  • tennis Scholastic Schedule:


    PV at Ledgemont (4:30)
    North at Geneva (4:30)
    Riverside at Chardon (4:30)
    Jefferson at Lakeview (5)

    April 16, 2014 1 Photo

  • Luke Baldwin Mustang to a Quaker

    As a junior, Grand Valley’s Luke Baldwin got a shot to play linebacker for the Mustangs because of an injury to a starter.

    April 15, 2014 1 Photo

  • Don A Don McCormack column: Kids’ stuff but, boy, was it a blast!

    I have no idea why I thought of this, just now, but I did.

    April 15, 2014 1 Photo

  • Scholastic Statistics:

    Chalker 4, Grand Valley 3
    at Chalker

    April 15, 2014

  • Megan Stech Scholastic Schedule:


    Geneva at Conneaut (4:30)
    Grand Valley at Windham (4:30)
    Edgewood at Niles (5)
    Maplewood at PV (4:30)
    Perry at West Geauga (4:30)
    Jefferson at Hubbard (5)

    April 15, 2014 1 Photo

  • ACBF POY Hoops celebration

    The Conneaut Human Resources Center was the place to be for local basketball aficionados on Sunday afternoon.

    April 14, 2014 1 Photo

  • ACBF HOF HOFers very appreciative

    Members of the Star Beacon All-Ashtabula County teams had a rare chance to listen to the stories of the players who came before them. Hearing the Ashtabula County Basketball Foundation Hall of Fame inductees speak at the 2014 Awards Dinner at the Conneaut Human Resources Center on Sunday put their careers in perspective.

    April 14, 2014 1 Photo

Sports Week in Review April 7-12
Spring Sports Practice in Ashtabula County
2014 AP BB Tourney Top 25
2014 AP BB Tourney Scoreboard
2014 AP BB Tourney News
2014 AP BB Tourney Photos
Star Beacon-Ed Batanian Senior Classic
Girls Regional Basketball Action
Week of Champions
Sports Week in Review February 21, 22
Grand Valley at Edgewood Boys Basketball
Sports Week in Review Feb. 3 to 8
Sports Week in Review January 30 to Feb. 1
Sports Week in Review January 13-18
Sports Week in Review January 10 and 11
Sports Video Archive
House Ads
AP Video